40 Castle Street Β· Geneva, NY

Come Play In Geneva's Weirdest Mystery Spot

Vintage finds, pinball, weird soda, and whatever Cassie made at 2am β€” all under one roof. Part toy shop, part arcade, part art space, entirely off the beaten path.

πŸ“ 40 Castle St, Geneva NY πŸ•’ Thu–Sat 12–8 Β· Sun 12–5 πŸ“Έ @totalrecall315
The Gift Shop

Made-Here Finds

A rotating shelf of Cassie's own handmade goods β€” the stuff people screenshot before they even get in the car. New drops posted to Instagram first; grab them in store or ask about mail order.

The Soda Wall

A Wall Of Genuinely Unhinged Soda

Dozens of flavors rotating weekly β€” the kind of wall people take a lap around before deciding. A dare-a-friend favorite.

πŸ₯€

Fruity & Loud

πŸ§ͺ

Fizzy & Weird

🍬

Nostalgia Runs

😬

Dare You

The Stage

Now Playing

Instagram Reels embed goes here (SnapWidget / Elfsight, free tier)
The Calendar

What's Coming Up

Live music, workshops, swap meets, league nights β€” kept current from Cassie's phone, no code required.

Public event calendar embed goes here (Google Calendar or Luma)
The Map Room

Make A Day Of Castle Street

Total Recall is one stop on a very good afternoon downtown. Here's who else to visit.

Map embed Β· 40 Castle St, Geneva NY

β˜• Stomping Grounds

Coffee before (or during) the browsing.

🌿 Marilla's Mindful Supplies

A calmer kind of shopping next door.

🚢 + Downtown Geneva

Add your own favorites here.

The Office

The Short Version

Total Recall is Cassie Sneider's shop on Castle Street β€” part toy store, part vintage shop, part pinball arcade, part whatever she's building this month. The front window still claims to belong to the Geneva Society for Cryptic Sightings and Hauntings β€” a joke, mostly β€” and a bookcase in the back office slides open to reveal the rest of the store.

The arcade room exists because a group of Geneva Middle School students pitched the idea to City Council. It's that kind of place β€” a little bit community project, a little bit fever dream, entirely worth the drive.